CISA credential leak raises alarms, and Capitol Hill demands answers

Congressional Democrats want answers from the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency about the reported public exposure of sensitive agency credential data on GitHub in an incident that the security researcher who discovered it called one of the worst leaks he’s ever seen.

Other security professionals also voiced concern Tuesday about the leak and the potential for abuse by any malicious parties who got a hold of the information.

Security firm GitGuardian said it discovered a public GitHub repository last week that exposed credentials for privileged AWS GovCloud accounts and internal CISA systems dating back to November. The repository, apparently maintained by a contractor, was named “Private-CISA.” 

Krebs on Security first reported the incident.

“My main fear … is that a state actor will get the data and might be able to do bad stuff,” GitGuardian security researcher Guillaume Valadon told CyberScoop that he thought to himself upon discovering the leak, after concluding it was real; he initially thought it looked fake.

State-based attackers who obtained the credentials “might be able to gain persistence,” Valadon said, “so for me it’s even worse than an attacker destroying everything, having someone in a governmental system — it’s really, really bad.”

Mississippi Rep. Bennie Thompson, the top Democrat on the Homeland Security Committee, and Delia Ramirez, the top Democrat on the panel’s cyber subcommittee, demanded a briefing Tuesday in a letter to CISA’s acting director, Nick Andersen. 

They said they wanted to learn “how this serious security lapse occurred, any potential security consequences, remediation activities, corrective actions related to the contractor personnel involved, and efforts to monitor for and prevent similar activity from occurring in the future.”

Sen. Maggie Hassan, D-N.H., also sent a letter Tuesday to Andersen, seeking a classified briefing to answer questions about which systems were exposed, what forensic work CISA did to evaluate potential damage and what corrective action it has taken.

“This reported incident raises serious questions about how such a security lapse could occur at the very agency charged with helping to prevent cyber breaches,” Hassan wrote in the missive first reported by Axios, particularly “regarding CISA’s internal policies and procedures at a time of significant cybersecurity threats against U.S. critical infrastructure.”

Both letters pointed to personnel and budget cutbacks at the agency as a potential contributor to the incident.

CISA said it was looking into what happened.

“The Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency is aware of the reported exposure and is continuing to investigate the situation,” a spokesperson said. “Currently, there is no indication that any sensitive data was compromised as a result of this incident. While we hold our team members to the highest standards of integrity and operational awareness, we are working to ensure additional safeguards are implemented to prevent future occurrences.” 

The repository was reportedly maintained by a contractor at Nightwing. A Nightwing spokesperson referred questions to CISA.

The kind of exposure that happened for CISA “is an unfortunately painful, but common and repeated, if not relentless, way that we see organizations inadvertently leak very sensitive credentials to the wider web,” said Ben Harris, founder of WatchTowr, a firm that helps organizations detect such exposures.

Harris told CyberScoop he didn’t want to speculate on what attackers who obtained the credentials might be able to do with it, but he said that it would be “terrifying” if the contractor was transferring information from work to home, as one researcher theorized.

Dave Mitchell, senior director of threat intelligence at Infoblox, told CyberScoop the incident showed the importance of teams having controls and audits in place across their repositories.

“Of all the things that keep me up at night, misconfigurations in GitHub are a recurring nightmare. It’s critical for so many organizations — all it takes is one accidental upload or misconfiguration and you’ve signed yourself up for a major incident,” he said in a written statement. “No need for a threat actor to use advanced techniques to compromise you if the keys are already sitting on the counter.”

Travis Rosiek, public sector chief technology officer at Rubrik, noted that the timing of the issue aligned with the government shutdown that only recently resolved for DHS. He said the incident showed the federal government needs to prioritize resilience.

“A persistent shortage of cybersecurity talent, combined with funding lapses, high workforce turnover, and an increasingly complex threat landscape, created the perfect storm for this scenario,” he said in a written statement to CyberScoop. “No organization is immune, and we must ensure that the federal government, which is responsible for helping protect the nation’s critical infrastructure and enhancing our cybersecurity posture, remains fully operational 24-7, 365 days a year.”

Without minimizing the severity of the incident, some researchers who have looked at the leak said there are mitigating circumstances that make elements of it defensible or, at least, understandable.

CISA acted very swiftly to remove the repository, Valadon said, once he alerted them to the leak.

And even if CISA has the right policies in place, human error still can make it difficult to entirely avoid incidents like this, Harris said.

“The reality is this happens every single day to different organizations, including cybersecurity corporations,” he said, noting it would be different if it was a pattern. “This is not exclusive to CISA. I don’t really think it reflects well if we saw this every single day with CISA. … It’s not ideal that it’s even happened once, but the reality is that cybersecurity is people, process, technology.”

CISA has had other security incidents in the past, including recently. The former acting director of the agency endured criticism for uploading sensitive contract data to ChatGPT last year. In 2024 the agency notified Congress of a breach of a chemical plant security tool.

The post CISA credential leak raises alarms, and Capitol Hill demands answers appeared first on CyberScoop.